The Heartbeat of Bay Shore's Rich History
The Early Years - A Legacy in the Making
Bay Shore, originally purchased from the Native Americans in 1701 and formally established by an English Royal Patent in 1708, has long embraced its unique heritage as a waterfront community. The area’s earliest settlers relied on fishing, clamming, woodcutting, and salt hay harvesting for their livelihood, with the Great South Bay serving as their lifeline.
The Resort Era - Bay Shore’s Appeal
In the late 1800s, Bay Shore became known as "The Garden Spot of Long Island" due to its appeal as a resort destination. Early entrepreneurs constructed several renowned hotels and inns, including the Dominy House, Prospect House, and Cortland House. The area attracted many famous and affluent visitors, some of whom made Bay Shore their home along its scenic, tree-lined streets and waterfront views.
A Timeless Charm
Today, Bay Shore maintains its quaint, village-like feel while being a thriving community. Its Main Street continues to serve as a hub for retail specialty shops and family-owned businesses, proudly standing as a testament to its early founders and picturesque waterfront.
Bay Shore’s Landmarks - A Glimpse Into the Past
Steeped in tradition, Bay Shore’s landmarks offer a window into its early 1900s past. These historic sites remind us of the town's growth and charm as a vibrant community by the bay.
The Railroad’s Impact on Growth
With the arrival of the railroad in the late 1800s, Bay Shore experienced significant expansion. The downtown area flourished, solidifying Bay Shore’s reputation as a bustling community while retaining the charm of its fishing village roots. Victorian homes, canals, marinas, and docks continue to define the area’s character.
Commitment to Education and Excellence
Academic Achievements and Innovations
Bay Shore Schools consistently exceed state and national averages in SAT scores. The district offers advanced courses, including opportunities for college credits, and is part of the state’s Universal Pre-K pilot program. Students excel in academics, athletics, and the arts, earning numerous awards and scholarships.
Bay Shore’s Educational Legacy
For over a century, the Bay Shore Union Free School District has upheld exceptional academic standards, enrolling over 5,000 students with a dedicated staff of 750.
A Wide Range of Educational Choices
In addition to public schools, Bay Shore offers several private and parochial schools, including St. Patrick's and St. Peter’s-by-the-Sea Day School, known for their long-standing traditions of academic excellence.
Strengthening Families and Community Connections
Building Strong Families
Since 1991, the Great South Bay YMCA has been a cornerstone of the Bay Shore community. The 55,000-square-foot facility, which includes health, aquatic, recreation, and child-care services, expanded in 1998 with the addition of the Martha and William Entenmann Pavilion. The YMCA’s programs support children, teens, and families, fostering strong, healthy communities.
A Center of Knowledge
Serving the community for over a century, the Bay Shore-Brightwaters Public Library is an essential resource for residents of all ages. With a wide range of educational, cultural, and recreational programs, the library is a vibrant community hub that offers workshops, meeting rooms, and a wealth of opportunities for personal and intellectual growth.
Celebrating Togetherness
Located in Dr. George S. King Park, the Bay Shore Community Band Shell brings the town together year-round for special events, such as concerts, parades, and holiday celebrations. This gathering place fosters a sense of community and tradition, helping to keep Bay Shore’s spirit strong and united.
A Community We Are Proud to Call Home
Bay Shore - A True American Community
Bay Shore is a community where neighbors wave to each other, families work hard to make ends meet, and cars are a part of daily life. Residents lead diverse lifestyles—some embrace active living, while others enjoy more relaxed days.
The Heart of the South Shore
Known as the heart of the South Shore, Bay Shore is a friendly and welcoming place. Residents take pride in their community, supporting local businesses, maintaining strong family values, and creating a close-knit atmosphere.
Worship - A House for All Faiths
A Tapestry of Faiths in Bay Shore
Bay Shore is home to a rich tapestry of religious communities. Over 20 recognized houses of worship serve the diverse spiritual needs of the area, representing Christian, Jewish, Muslim, Hindu, and independent faiths. These churches and synagogues are integral to the community, offering a space for worship, reflection, and support.
Uniting Through Faith
The United Methodist Church, Bethel A.M.E. Church, Bay Shore Jewish Centre, St. Patrick Roman Catholic Church, and St. Luke’s Lutheran Church are just a few of the many faith communities in the area. The Interfaith Clergy Association works to bring together people from all walks of life, fostering mutual respect and understanding among the different faiths and providing support to those in need.
One Vision of Service Among Many Faiths
Whether housed in a historic 19th-century building or a modern structure, each house of worship in Greater Bay Shore shares one vision—serving the community. These places of worship offer counseling, outreach programs, and a welcoming space for all, ensuring that everyone is supported regardless of their background or beliefs.
Lifestyle on the Waterfront
Proximity to Pristine Beaches
Bay Shore offers unparalleled access to the scenic Robert Moses Beach and Jones Beach. On warm summer days, families flock to the soft sands and refreshing waters, enjoying the idyllic beauty of Fire Island’s beaches just minutes away. With a vibrant waterfront community, Bay Shore is the perfect destination for beach goers, sailors, and outdoor enthusiasts.
A Haven for Water Enthusiasts
Fishing, boating, and sailing thrive on the Great South Bay. Pleasure fishermen can be seen along the docks or aboard bay and ocean charter boats, seeking flounder, fluke, and bass. Generations of commercial baymen continue their work on the sea, contributing to the local heritage and economy.
Endless Access to Water and Nature
Residents enjoy easy access to both bay and ocean beaches, as well as thousands of acres of nearby parkland and wildlife preserves. The diverse landscapes offer opportunities for outdoor recreation, from fishing to hiking, making Bay Shore a paradise for nature lovers.
The Crown Jewel - Bay Shore Marina
Bay Shore Marina stands as one of the largest publicly owned marinas on the East Coast. This hub of nautical activity provides year-round enjoyment for residents, with direct access to the waters of Great South Bay.
Take the Next Step
Excited to be part of our dynamic community? Contact the Chamber of Commerce of Greater Bay Shore today to learn how you can get involved, grow your business, and experience all that Bay Shore has to offer!